The Small Business HR Software Buyer’s Guide: Features, Comparisons & Compliance
Choosing HR software for your small business? Compare must-have features, HRIS vs. HRMS vs. HCM, and learn why background screening belongs in every hiring workflow.
Resourcesarticles
Wing Poon
15 min read
Click a chapter to scroll directly to it.
An applicant tracking system (ATS) is recruiting software that stores job openings and applicant records and moves each candidate through defined hiring stages, from requisition and application through screening, interviews, communications and offer. Employers use an ATS to keep hiring organized, consistent and documented in one place instead of across inboxes and spreadsheets.
An applicant tracking system is the system of record for hiring before someone becomes an employee. It holds each open role, every person who applies to it, where each candidate stands, who has reviewed them, what was said to them and why they moved forward or did not.
Several people typically work in the same ATS:
Some ATS products also include candidate relationship management (CRM) features for keeping in touch with people who have not applied yet. The core job of an ATS, though, is managing people who have applied to a specific opening.
Most ATS products follow the same basic sequence. The labels differ by product, but the steps below map to how most small and midsize employers hire.
A requisition is the approved request to fill a role. It usually records the job title, department, hiring manager, location, pay range, headcount and who approved it. Once the requisition is approved, the ATS publishes the job to your careers page and, depending on the product, to connected job boards. Every application that follows is tied back to that requisition, which makes later reporting and recordkeeping much easier.
Each applicant gets a record, and the ATS tracks that record through a series of stages you define. A simple pipeline might look like this:
| Stage | What happens | What the ATS should record |
|---|---|---|
| Applied | Application and resume received | Date, source, the role applied for |
| Screen | Recruiter reviews qualifications or holds a short phone screen | Reviewer, outcome, screening notes |
| Interview | Hiring manager or panel interviews | Interviewers, dates, scorecards |
| Offer | Offer approved and extended, often conditional | Approver, offer terms, date sent |
| Background check | Screening ordered after candidate consent | Consent status, check status, final hiring decision |
| Hired | Candidate accepts and starts onboarding | Start date, handoff to your HR system |
| Not selected or withdrew | Candidate exits at any stage | Stage, date and a consistent reason |
The last row matters more than it looks. Recording a consistent reason each time a candidate leaves the process (sometimes called a disposition) helps you explain decisions later and spot stages where qualified people drop out.
Screening tools range from simple knockout questions, such as whether the candidate holds a required license, to keyword filters and AI-based ranking. These tools can save time, but they also shape who a person ever sees. A 2026 Stanford study of one vendor’s AI screening tool, covering about 4 million applications, found racial disparities in its recommendations when postings were analyzed one at a time.
Some jurisdictions regulate automated screening directly. New York City’s Local Law 144 generally requires a bias audit and candidate notice before an employer uses an automated employment decision tool, and the city began enforcing it on July 5, 2023. Illinois amended its Human Rights Act, effective January 1, 2026, to address discriminatory effects of AI in employment decisions and to require notice when employers use it. Rules in this area are changing in several states, so check the law where you hire before turning on automated ranking or rejection features.
An ATS usually connects to company calendars so recruiters can offer interview slots, send invitations and reschedule without long email chains. Many systems also provide interview scorecards, which ask each interviewer to rate the same job-related criteria. Scorecards keep feedback in one place and make it easier to compare candidates on the same basis.
Templates for application confirmations, interview invitations, status updates and rejection messages help every candidate hear from you on a predictable schedule. Because messages are sent from the ATS, the candidate record keeps a history of what was said and when, which is useful if a candidate later asks about their application.
When the team selects a finalist, the ATS typically manages offer approval and the offer letter. Many employers make offers conditional on a background check. At this point the process moves partly outside the ATS, because the background check is prepared by a separate screening provider under different rules.
An ATS tracks candidates. It does not compile background check reports. Those come from a consumer reporting agency, and the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) sets steps the employer must follow when it uses one. Under FTC and EEOC guidance, the employer must:
State and local laws can add steps. Some places limit when an employer may ask about criminal history, in some cases not until after a conditional offer. GoodHire’s ban-the-box guide explains how these fair chance laws generally work. Your ATS stages should reflect whichever rules apply where you hire.
| Mistake | Why it matters | What to set up in your workflow |
|---|---|---|
| Ordering a check before the candidate signs the disclosure and authorization | The FCRA requires written authorization first | Make signed consent a required step before a check can be ordered |
| Placing the disclosure inside the job application | The FTC says the notice cannot be in an employment application | Keep the disclosure as a separate document, sent at the screening stage |
| Moving a candidate to “not selected” as soon as a report arrives | Pre-adverse action notice and time to respond come before a final decision | Add a stage for pending adverse action so the candidate is not closed out early |
| Screening some finalists for a role but not others | FTC and EEOC guidance calls for applying the same standards to everyone | Define which checks apply to each role in advance |
| Leaving screening turnaround out of hiring timelines | Start dates can slip while a check is still in progress | Track check status and build typical turnaround time into offer planning |
Many screening providers connect to ATS products so recruiters can start a check from the candidate record. GoodHire is not an ATS. Its HR tech integrations page says employers can launch background checks from within their existing workflow to get FCRA-compliant consent from candidates, securely access screening results and view candidate information alongside those results. GoodHire’s integrations page lists platforms including Greenhouse, iCIMS, Jobvite, Lever, SmartRecruiters, BambooHR and Workday, and says it can integrate with other platforms through its API. What an integration can do may vary by platform, so confirm the details for your system.
From Checkr research
Hiring workflows, by the numbers
From recent surveys by Checkr, GoodHire’s parent company:
Sources: Checkr, Unlocking HR’s Strategic Potential With Better Verifications (2026 survey of 1,000 senior HR leaders at organizations with 1,000+ employees); Hiring Disconnect (2025 survey of 3,000 US job seekers).
An ATS covers people who are applying. A human resources information system (HRIS) covers people who work for you. When a candidate is hired, their information typically passes from the ATS to the HRIS, which is where onboarding, employee records and often payroll and benefits live.
| System | Main job | Who it covers | Typical records |
|---|---|---|---|
| Applicant tracking system (ATS) | Run hiring from requisition to accepted offer | Applicants and candidates | Requisitions, applications, stages, interview feedback, candidate messages |
| HRIS or HR platform | Manage the employee relationship after hire | Employees | Personnel files, job and pay history, time off, benefits |
| Payroll software | Pay employees and handle payroll taxes | Employees | Pay rates, tax withholding, pay statements |
| Background screening provider | Prepare background check reports | Candidates and employees who authorize a check | Consent forms, reports, adverse action notices |
Some all-in-one HR platforms include a light ATS, and some ATS products include onboarding tools, so the lines can blur. For choosing HR, payroll and onboarding platforms more broadly, see GoodHire’s guide to HR software for small business.
Your ATS is often the main place hiring records live, so its retention settings matter. Under EEOC regulations at 29 CFR 1602.14, employers covered by federal anti-discrimination laws generally must keep application forms and other hiring records for one year from when the record was made or the personnel action was taken, whichever is later. If a discrimination charge is filed, relevant records must be kept until the charge and any related lawsuit are finally resolved. State laws may require longer retention.
The federal Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures also call for covered employers to keep information on how their selection procedures affect applicants by sex, race and ethnic group, with a simplified approach for smaller employers. If you collect race or ethnicity information for this purpose, the EEOC describes keeping it separate from the materials used to evaluate candidates, for example with a tear-off sheet. In an ATS, that usually means voluntary self-identification answers that hiring managers cannot see.
Federal contractors have had additional recordkeeping rules. The Department of Labor’s Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) issued final rules in August 2026 that rescind its Executive Order 11246 regulations and revise other contractor requirements, so contractors should confirm which obligations still apply to them.
Before you compare products, write down how you hire today: who approves roles, how many openings you fill in a year, who interviews and where candidates drop off. Then use these questions in demos and trials.
If you fill only a few roles a year, a structured spreadsheet and a shared inbox may still work. The signs you have outgrown them are usually lost candidates, inconsistent communication and difficulty answering who was considered for a role and why.
An applicant tracking system (ATS) is software that keeps track of job openings and the people who apply to them. It records where each candidate is in the hiring process, who reviewed them and what was communicated. Employers use it to keep hiring organized and documented in one place.
An ATS manages candidates before they are hired, from application through offer. An HRIS manages employees after they are hired, including personnel records and often payroll and benefits. When a candidate is hired, their information typically moves from the ATS into the HRIS.
No. An ATS tracks candidates, but background check reports come from a background screening provider, which is a consumer reporting agency under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Many screening providers integrate with ATS products so employers can start a check and follow its status from the candidate record. The employer remains responsible for the FCRA disclosure, authorization and adverse action steps.
EEOC regulations generally require covered employers to keep application forms and other hiring records for one year from when the record was made or the personnel action was taken, whichever is later. If a discrimination charge is filed, relevant records must be kept until it is finally resolved. State laws and federal contractor rules may add requirements, so check what applies to you.
Not always. Employers that fill only a few roles a year may manage with a structured spreadsheet and a shared inbox. An ATS becomes more useful when candidates start getting lost, communication becomes inconsistent or it is hard to show who was considered for a role and why.
The resources provided here are for educational purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. We advise you to consult your own counsel if you have legal questions related to your specific practices and compliance with applicable laws.
Follow Me
Wing Poon focuses on helping small businesses thrive. He’s spent his career launching products that help small businesses accomplish more—at Appodeal, Envoy, and now at Checkr. Outside of work, his podcast on work and purpose led to his own discovery, now expressed through his travel video storytelling.
Choosing HR software for your small business? Compare must-have features, HRIS vs. HRMS vs. HCM, and learn why background screening belongs in every hiring workflow.
Learn how to run a background check for employment to make informed, fair, and compliant hiring decisions
Track the HR metrics that matter most: recruiting, retention, and engagement. Get formulas, benchmarks, and a prioritization framework built for growing SMBs.