Infractions, Misdemeanors & Felonies: What Employers Find On Criminal Background Checks
When reviewing a criminal background check, it’s important to understand how offenses are categorized by relative severity, class or level.
Resourcesarticles
Jeff Boggess
15 min read
Click a chapter to scroll directly to it.
A misdemeanor conviction generally stays on a person’s criminal record indefinitely unless it is sealed, expunged, set aside or cleared under a state law. How long it can appear on an employment background check is a separate question. Federal law sets no time limit for reporting convictions, while some states limit reporting to seven years.
For employers, the practical answer depends on three separate questions: whether the record still exists, whether a background check report may include it, and whether the employer may lawfully consider it. Different laws answer each one, and the answers can differ for the same record.
Much of the confusion about misdemeanor records comes from treating three different questions as one. The table below separates them.
| Question | What controls the answer | Example |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Does the record still exist? | State court and records rules, including sealing, expungement, set-aside and pardon processes | A misdemeanor conviction from 15 years ago generally remains in court records unless it was cleared. |
| 2. Can a background check report include it? | The FCRA and state consumer reporting laws, which apply to background check companies | Federal law allows the 15-year-old conviction to be reported. California law generally does not. |
| 3. May the employer consider it? | Title VII and EEOC guidance, state and local fair chance laws, and FCRA adverse action rules | In New York, an employer must weigh factors such as time elapsed and evidence of rehabilitation before denying a job based on a conviction. |
Generally, not on its own. A misdemeanor is a criminal offense that is less serious than a felony (see our comparison of felonies, misdemeanors and infractions). A conviction usually remains in court files and state criminal history databases unless a legal process clears or restricts it. The terms and effects vary by state:
Most of these remedies traditionally required the person to petition a court. A number of states have adopted clean slate laws that clear some eligible records automatically. Two examples, confirmed against official state sources:
In California, a person can ask a court to dismiss an eligible misdemeanor conviction, and some convictions may already have been dismissed automatically by the state Department of Justice, according to the California Courts self-help guide. Eligibility, waiting periods and effects differ in every state, so the official court or state source for the relevant jurisdiction is the place to check.
A conviction record results from a guilty plea, a no-contest plea or a guilty verdict. A non-conviction record includes an arrest that did not lead to charges, a charge that was dismissed, an acquittal and, in some states, a case dismissed after a diversion program. Dismissed charges usually remain in court files unless they are sealed or expunged.
The difference matters because federal and state reporting laws treat the two categories differently, as the next section explains.
The FCRA governs background check reports prepared by consumer reporting agencies (CRAs), the companies that compile background checks for employers. Its time limits appear in 15 U.S.C. § 1681c:
Some states add their own limits, and a state rule may apply even when the FCRA would allow reporting. Two examples:
Other states set their own rules, and some limit reporting based on where the candidate lives or works. GoodHire’s guide to how far back background checks go summarizes state lookback periods.
Two further points affect what a report shows. First, the FCRA limits apply to CRAs. An employer that searches court records itself is not using a consumer report, but anti-discrimination law and some state laws still apply to how it uses what it finds. Second, clearing a record does not always remove it from private databases immediately. The EEOC’s enforcement guidance notes that a court order sealing or expunging a record does not guarantee that private companies will purge the information.
A record that can lawfully appear on a report is not automatically a record an employer should rely on. Several layers of law apply.
Federal anti-discrimination guidance. The EEOC’s 2012 guidance under Title VII says an arrest alone does not establish criminal conduct, so excluding someone based only on an arrest is not job related and consistent with business necessity. An employer may consider the conduct underlying an arrest if that conduct makes the person unfit for the job. For convictions, the guidance points to three factors: the nature and gravity of the offense, the time elapsed, and the nature of the job. It recommends an individualized assessment, which gives the person a chance to explain their circumstances. The guidance also notes that offenses identified as misdemeanors may be less severe than felonies.
State laws on use. Some states restrict what employers may use regardless of what appears on a report. For example:
Timing rules. Ban-the-box and fair chance laws in many states and cities control when an employer may ask about criminal history, and some add their own notice and waiting-period steps.
Time since the offense. Research summarized by the National Institute of Justice found that, after enough time without a new arrest, the risk posed by a person with a prior record can become similar to that of comparable people without one. The time needed depended on factors such as age at first arrest and offense type. This supports treating an older misdemeanor differently from a recent one.
From Checkr research
Criminal records and hiring, by the numbers
In a 2023 survey of 2,000 US business leaders by Checkr, GoodHire’s parent company:
Source: Checkr, Criminal Records and Fair Chance Hiring (2023 survey of 2,000 US business leaders).
This table summarizes how the three questions typically play out for common misdemeanor record types. State and local law can change the outcome, so treat it as a starting point for review with counsel, not a rule.
| Record type | May it appear on a report? | What employers should consider |
|---|---|---|
| Misdemeanor conviction, recent | Generally yes | Whether it is job related, applying the nature, time and job factors and any state or local fair chance rules |
| Misdemeanor conviction, more than seven years old | Yes under the FCRA; restricted in some states, such as California | Whether the state allowed it to be reported, and how much weight the time elapsed deserves |
| Arrest or dismissed charge | Generally only within the FCRA’s seven-year window unless the salary exception applies; barred in some states, such as New York | An arrest alone is not a basis for rejection under EEOC guidance; some states, such as California, bar using it |
| Pending charge | Generally yes | The underlying conduct and its relation to the job, subject to state and local rules |
| Sealed, expunged or dismissed conviction | Generally should not appear once the order takes effect, though databases can lag | Many states bar using these records; confirm the status with the candidate and the CRA |
Common mistakes to avoid include assuming the seven-year rule removes convictions everywhere, applying the FCRA’s $75,000 exception to state rules that have a different threshold or none, and relying on a record that a state has sealed or bars employers from using.
Candidates who want to know what an employer might see can request their state criminal history record, check the relevant court’s guidance on sealing or expungement, and ask a legal aid organization or attorney about eligibility. If a background check contains inaccurate or incomplete information, the FCRA gives the candidate the right to dispute it with the CRA that prepared the report.
Generally, no. A misdemeanor conviction usually stays in court and state records unless it is sealed, expunged, set aside or cleared under a state law. Some states, including Connecticut and Michigan, now clear certain eligible misdemeanors automatically after a waiting period, while others require a court petition.
Yes, in many cases. The federal FCRA sets no time limit for reporting convictions, so a misdemeanor conviction can appear regardless of age unless state law or a sealing or expungement order restricts it. Some states, such as California, generally bar reporting convictions older than seven years.
It can. A dismissed charge is a non-conviction record, which the FCRA generally allows background check companies to report for seven years, unless the job is expected to pay $75,000 or more a year. Some states, such as New York, bar reporting it at all, and EEOC guidance says an arrest alone is not a valid basis for rejecting a candidate.
They generally should not once the sealing or expungement order takes effect, but private databases may not update right away. If a cleared record appears, the candidate can dispute it with the background check company. Many states also bar employers from using sealed or dismissed records.
Under Michigan’s Clean Slate law, automatic set-asides took effect April 11, 2023. Eligible misdemeanors are set aside seven years after sentencing if the person has no pending charges and no new convictions in that period. Limits and exclusions apply, such as for assaultive crimes, serious misdemeanors and operating while intoxicated.
Sometimes. Under EEOC guidance, an employer should consider the nature and gravity of the offense, the time elapsed and the nature of the job, and many state and local laws add further limits. An employer that relies on a background check must also follow the FCRA’s adverse action steps.
The resources provided here are for educational purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. We advise you to consult your own counsel if you have legal questions related to your specific practices and compliance with applicable laws.
Follow Me
Jeff Boggess covers criminal background checks, motor vehicle records (MVR), DOT compliance, and international screening at Checkr, along with the technology behind them: Checkr AI, accuracy programs, and the people data graph. He focuses on turning complex screening regulations and public records data into practical guidance for employers.
When reviewing a criminal background check, it’s important to understand how offenses are categorized by relative severity, class or level.
Background checks look for different results and cover different lengths of time. Learn about the length of history that can be checked legally and used compliantly.
What terms appear on a criminal background check, and how should employers read them? Learn how to read and understand them in a few simple steps.